Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts

Friday, 6 November 2015

Plato, the Ancient Greeks and the idea of Sovereignty [THIRD PART]

The Ancient Greeks did not have a dedicated theory about the idea of sovereignty but they developed the conceptualisation of State and its implications so we in fact are able to at least have hints about their thoughts in regards also to sovereignty.


Plato sets up the basis from where the Greek philosophers and thinkers (even the modern ones) depart. Plato understands that we are in presence of a State “when we have got hold of enough people to satisfy our many varied needs, we have assembled quite a large number of partners and helpers together to live in one place […]”.[1] He summarised with his conceptualisation all the elements we consider nowadays essential for the existence of a State: population, territory, government. Note that law is not mentioned but will be present throughout his work.



With The Republic “[…] there seems reason to believe it was monarchy which claimed [Plato’s] allegiance. A famous sentence of the Republic tells us, that there will be no rest from their troubles for the cities of Greece or for all mankind, until the days of philosopher kings; and from the Politicus we also learn the necessity of ideal and absolute monarchy. […] Reason, being one and indivisible, rules the spirit and the multitude of desires in the individual mind: reason, incarnate in one sovereign, must rule all other classes in the State. In such a sovereign the theories of the Republic culminate. […]The Platonic theory of monarchy is expounded in the Politicus”.[2]  However interesting, this point is not relevant here. Plato revaluates several forms of governments from different angles. It is true he considers monarchy as the best option in theory but he knows—being a pragmatic—that democracy results more feasible. The key detail for here: the sovereignty of a State remains a “human” attribute.

Let us turn the attention to what Plato says in the Politicus in relation to the Guardians, representatives, statesman or government:

“[…] we started by taking theoretical knowledge and distinguishing an instructional part of if, and we then drew on an analogy to make up the term ‘producer-instructional’ for a further subdivision. Next, within this ‘producer-instructional’ branch we isolated the not unimportant art of maintaining creatures. We found that a category of creature-maintenance was herd-maintenance, and that a category of herd-maintenance in its turn was the herding of creatures with feet. Within the herding of creatures with feet, the crucial segment we distinguished was the art of maintaining those which lack horns. And if you want to encapsulate in a single term the relevant subdivision of this art of maintaining creatures which lack horns, you have to combine at least three components and call it the branch of knowledge which is concerned with ‘the herding of species which cannot interbreed’. As for subdividing this class, since the art of herding human beings is the only section left which deals with two-footed gregarious creatures, then it is exactly what we are after – the art we’ve been calling both kingship and statesmanship”.[3]

Indeed, it seems Plato introduces a simple classification. But after more careful consideration we may see that he presents the elements that integrated—and still do —the theory of a ruler and the State: gregarious two-footed creatures (we would add, with consciousness) that are used to being in groups. He assumes they will have needs and in order to better cover their needs they will need direction; hence, the reciprocal relation represented-representative—i.e. sovereignty and its reflection. For the ones into political sciences and political theory, a very early reference to Nozick and his “aggregations.”

Another key development evident in Plato’s work: having different options in terms of forms of government, it is only one that truly reflects the idea of public sovereignty: “[…] ‘dictatorship’ is the term for the management by constraint of unwilling subjects, whereas ‘statesmanship’ is the term for the management by consent of willing, two-footed, gregarious creatures. So [the one] […] with this particular kind of managerial expertise is a true statesman-king […]”.[4]

As it has previously been mentioned in this post, it is clear Plato’s preference for monarchy but being a practical thinker and having experienced many realities throughout his life he concedes that “[…] in other cities there had been a development which had almost everywhere followed the same order, from monarchy to aristocracy, from aristocracy to tyranny, from tyranny to democracy”.[5]

For that reason it is at least hard to agree with Barker when he concludes that “[t]he statesman has an infinite complexity of circumstances, an infinite variety of characters, to handle; and like a physician, he must be left untrammelled by any book of laws, if he is to handle them as he should. The variability of his matter demands a corresponding flexibility in his power. States which bind their rulers to act according to law lose that flexibility. [...] The ideal of Plato would thus appear to be the absolute monarch of a subject people, unfettered by public opinion and unhampered by law”.[6] From The Republic to the Politicus and the Laws a common thread may be identified: sovereignty as an attribute of the people that are the polis. 

The idea of the representative evolves as his works and mostly his experience do so. Although he is inclined at first for a monarch ruling with absolute power he later on understands the idea of democracy as a better and more practical solution. It is important to highlight once again: sovereignty remains in all his works within the society. That society because of its needs requires representation. The representatives (or Guardians) are a reflection of the people’s will. Having one person representing them or a group does not change the essence of his idea.

Next time Plato’s Statesman.



[1] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 58.

[2] Barker, Ernest, The political thought of Plato and Aristotle, Dover Publications Inc., 1959, pp. 164/165.

[3] Plato, Statesman, translated by R. Waterfield, Cambridge texts in the History of political thought, 1995, pp. 18/19.

[4] Plato, Statesman, translated by R. Waterfield, Cambridge texts in the History of political thought, 1995, p. 32.

[5] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 3.

[6] Barker, Ernest, The political thought of Plato and Aristotle, Dover Publications Inc., 1959, p. 167/168.

Friday, 30 October 2015

Plato, the Ancient Greeks and the idea of Sovereignty [SECOND PART]

The Ancient Greeks did not have a dedicated theory about the idea of sovereignty but they developed the conceptualisation of State and its implications so we in fact are able to at least have hints about their thoughts in regards also to sovereignty.


Plato sets up the basis from where the Greek philosophers and thinkers (even the modern ones) depart. Plato understands that we are in presence of a State “when we have got hold of enough people to satisfy our many varied needs, we have assembled quite a large number of partners and helpers together to live in one place […]”.[1] He summarised with his conceptualisation all the elements we consider nowadays essential for the existence of a State: population, territory, government. Note that law is not mentioned but will be present throughout his work.


It is time now to focus our attention on another element that is part of a sovereign State and the Ancient Greeks considered too: the government.


Plato is clear about the relationship between two elements of the equation: government and law: “[a]t any rate the next and necessary step in this amalgamation is to choose some representatives to review the rules of all the families, and to propose openly to the leaders and heads of the people – the ‘kings’ […]. These representatives will be known as lawgivers, and by appointing the leaders as officials they will create out the separate autocracies a sort of aristocracy, or perhaps a kingship”.[2] That is to say, the representatives of the people that live in a certain territory and the rules or norms that are used to allow their coexistence.  It is clear that Ancient Greek thinkers considered the government or representatives as a necessity or necessary condition—i.e. the population’s need to have a direction, a purpose.
In other words, Plato refers firstly to what we may understand nowadays as population and territory; secondly, their necessities. Depending on the context the representatives will be elected and the law will follow. The following quotation illustrates the point:
“There are two stages involved in organizing a society. First you establish official positions and appoint people to hold them: you decide how many posts there should be and how they ought to be filled. Then each office has to be given its particular laws […]”.[3]

Plato goes further by reviewing the qualities required in the Guardians (as he calls the representatives) or rulers: “[a]nd so our properly good Guardian will have the following characteristics: a philosophic disposition, high spirits, speed, and strength”.[4] He highlights here the idea of a “good representative” as a polar star to be aimed for. He is not being idealistic in the sense his dialogue is purely theoretical. He is only giving us a hint. That is the reason why he follows: “[a]nd it’s absolutely vital to give your best attention to choosing, first of all, Guardians of the Laws”[5] since they will be representing people’s will and in dong so they would have to excel, to stand out from the crowd due to their virtues. Indeed, the rulers had to be virtuous according to Plato, something that seems to have been forgotten after so many centuries and many of our current representatives should be reminded of.
People’s will is crucial. Without using the concept, Plato implicitly includes the notion of people’s sovereignty: “[s]o we must choose from among our Guardians those who appear to us on observation to be most likely to devote their lives to doing what they judge to be in the interest of the community, and who are never prepared to act against it”.[6]
At least in The Republic and the Politicus or the Statesman we can easily see the sovereign power rests o people’s shoulders. We can discuss if the sovereignty is an attribute of the population or of the representatives but it is definitely a human one. The Laws may suggest a change. However, I consider The Laws as a metaphor: if population and representatives are unable to coexist in an orderly manner, they create a “tool” in order to allow “civilised” relationships.

Plato will always aim for the best in everything. Being the representatives the pinnacle of a social system it is not strange that he requires from them the highest quality in terms of virtues (or excellences in a literal translation). The philosopher has the principal virtue (wisdom) that can balance the three key elements that are the essence of any human being: reason, spirit and appetite. So it is to be expected that:
“[t]he society we have described can never grow into reality or see the light of day, and there will be no end to the troubles of states, or indeed, […] of humanity itself, till philosophers become kings in this world, or till those we now call kings and rulers really and truly become philosophers […]”.[7]
Consequently, “[t]he ‘philosopher-king’ is not a mere addition or insertion: he is the logical result of the whole method on which the construction of the State has proceeded”.[8]

Next time The Laws, The Politicus, and The Republic.



[1] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 58.

[2] Plato, The Laws, translated by T. J. Saunders, Penguin Books, 1976, 125.

[3] Plato, The Laws, translated by T. J. Saunders, Penguin Books, 1976, p. 221.

[4] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 69.

[5] Plato, The Laws, translated by T. J. Saunders, Penguin Books, 1976, p. 223.

[6] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 119.

[7] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 203.
[8] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 170.

Friday, 16 October 2015

Plato, the Ancient Greeks and the idea of Sovereignty

We could fairly say that political life started the day two people had an opinion with regards kind of issue; therefore, almost at mankind’s inset. However, we agree with Barker that the “[p]olitical thought begins with the Greeks”. [1] Indeed, it is with them when the notions and institutions are analysed, simple and more complex concepts exposed and reviewed.

Specifically, they did not have a dedicated theory about the idea of sovereignty but they developed the conceptualisation of State and its implications so we in fact are able to at least have hints about their thoughts in regards also to sovereignty.


Plato sets up the basis from where the Greek philosophers and thinkers (even the modern ones) depart. Firstly, we will mention his definition of one of the key concepts here. Plato understands that we are in presence of a State “when we have got hold of enough people to satisfy our many varied needs, we have assembled quite a large number of partners and helpers together to live in one place […]”.[2]

He summarised with his conceptualisation all the elements we consider nowadays essential for the existence of a State: population, territory, government. Note that law is not mentioned but will be present throughout his work.
From here on we will focus our attention on three of his dialogues since they are the one related to the State, the law and sovereignty: The Republic, Politicus or Statesman and the Laws.

We agree with Baker again when he says: “[…] starting from an ethical point of view, and from the conception of the State as a moral association, Greek thought always postulated a solidarity which is foreign to most modern thinking. […] To modern thinker the mission of the State is negative: its function is the removal of hindrances (rather than the application of a stimulus) to the moral life”. [3] It is a fact, in Ancient Greece the origin of the State is explained as a necessity: “Men were ‘political animals’[…]”.[4] They are still part of a species that need the others to fulfil their needs.

Plato starts from the idea of individuals living alone and then congregated together in very small groups of three or four people. As it could be easily foreseen, people have various necessities (food, shelter, etc.). He observes here “[…] the origin of the state. It originates, as we have seen, from our needs”. [5] He goes even further with his theory proposing the idea of labour division: “[…] no two of us are born exactly alike. We have different natural aptitudes, which fit us for different jobs”. [6]

If we are still unsure whether he is using the concept as we use it nowadays, he highlights it again: “So do we do better to exercise one skill or to try to practise several? To stick to one, he said”. [7]

The next predictable consequences of these small groups of people living together will be the procreation and the formation of families. And having several families within a certain territory, they will start having relationships of different nature with each other in order to cover mutual needs, that is to say “[t]he next stage is when several families amalgamate and form larger communities”. [8]

Larger communities will have to satisfy larger needs. It would be inefficient for all people to perform the same tasks. The Ancient Greeks had already found a solution: “[…] every man should fulfil a single specific function already appears, in the shape of division of labour, in the first rudiments of the State. […] The desires for food and warmth and shelter cannot be properly satisfied, except by means of common action. The State first find its binding force in human need […] until it reaches the measure of an adult State”. [9] They go even further and consider of absolute necessity for the foundation of the new state the selection of the citizens and distributing the land. [10]

It results interesting indeed that they are developing, even at theoretical level, what modern thinkers consider two of the basic elements of any give State: population and territory. They are even realistic and leaving behind an only theoretical approach think about second class of needs any population may normally have: “Give them the ordinary comforts, he replied. Let them recline in comfort on couches and eat off tables, and have the sort of food we have today.  That is when a simple group of families or small and rudimentary society becomes a civilization. And that is the main objective in Plato’s work: “[…] We are to study not only the origins of society, but also society when it enjoys the luxuries of civilization”. [11]

More families, a larger community imply a larger variety of needs to be covered. The Greek response is once again both, practical and realistic: “We shall have to enlarge our state again. Our healthy state is no longer big enough; its size must be enlarged to make room for a multitude of occupations none of which is concerned with necessaries”. [12]

The notion of sovereignty is shaping. People have dominium over a certain territory but “the territory which was formerly enough to support [them] will now be too small”. [13] Additionaly, “[m]en are not content with the supply of the merest “necessaries”: they need satisfaction of their desires for refinement. […] a larger territory is necessary to support the larger population”. [14]

Before reviewing the consequences of the necessity with regards a larger territory, we will focus our attention next time on another element that is part of a sovereign State and the Ancient Greeks considered too: the government.



[1] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 1.

[2] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 58.

[3] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 7.

[4] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 17.

[5] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 59.

[6] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 59.

[7] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 60.

[8] Plato, The Laws, translated by T. J. Saunders, Penguin Books, 1976, p. 124.

[9] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 165.

[10] Plato, The Laws, translated by T. J. Saunders, Penguin Books, 1976, pp. 201/219.

[11] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 63.

[12] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 64.

[13] Plato, The Republic, translated by D. Lee, Penguin Books, 1987, p. 64.

[14] Barker, Ernest, Greek political theory: Plato and his predecessors, Methuen & Co., Ltd., 1951, p. 167.