Showing posts with label Catalonia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Catalonia. Show all posts

Friday, 5 June 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 30) [Post 115]


Referendum in Northern Ireland

The post yesterday argued that in cases such as Northern Ireland, a solution between status quo and complete independence should be reached in light of Brexit. We introduced the notion of self-determination. Today, the post explores the idea of having a referendum.

Assuming that because of Brexit, the British government decided to have a referendum in Northern Ireland, what options should be considered for referendum? Taking into account previous referendums in the United Kingdom (Falklands, Scotland, Brexit) it is possible to assume the question would read:


“Do you want Northern Ireland to be an independent state in the form of a republic? Yes/No.

This kind of referendum will not solve any issue. In fact, the government would know the question has one possible answer. Therefore, the referendum would only legitimize an already made decision. Let us consider two critical points:


  • Firstly, the referendum’s “value.” It is indeed important Northern Ireland could have a referendum as expression of democratic values and basic liberties. It is also a way to start breaking the status quo after Brexit.


  • Secondly, the importance of the actual question. Because of the way the question could be written and current international and local scenario, there could be but one answer. So, we all can foresee its result. That does not mean that the actual referendum is of no value. As stated before, it is a crucial moment (as it was the Falkland’s referendum in 2013 and in Scotland in 2014). More importantly, it ratifies the fact that Northern Ireland can make use of their right to self-determination at any time and propose any other referendum and solution.


Why does the question have problems?

The answer is simple. Because although it may seem as if the question offered a choice, it does not in reality. If Northern Ireland answered NO, and they decided to remain part of the United Kingdom, they would still be considered as British territory and hence would know what to expect. That is to say, they would continue living the way they live with the government and the law they know and all that this implies. However, if they answered YES, and Northern Ireland decided to be an independent state, the consequence is but one: uncertainty.

Many questions would be asked: does Northern Ireland automatically remain part of the European Union? Would they need to apply to join the EU as a newly formed state? Would they have the option of joining the Republic of Ireland? What currency would they use? And, many other questions related to natural resources, education system, healthcare. Result: who is going to choose uncertainty over something already known?

There are ways to address the indeterminacy in referendums and offer a clearer, more informed, better constructed question. That is, if the parties calling for a referendum actually aim to use the referendum as a democratic tool for self-determination rather than a tool for validation of predetermined and foreseeable decisions.


NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

The South China Sea (available on Monday 06th July 2020)
                   
Friday 05th June 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World

Thursday, 4 June 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 29) [Post 114]


Northern Ireland, self-determination and referendum


Brexit fuels a fair amount of rhetoric in relation to Northern Ireland. There are many questions: whether to have a soft or hard border, and even to leave the United Kingdom, join the Republic of Ireland and therefore, remain part of the European Union.
Often, there is a common thread. Rather than using legal and political theory for their arguments to support the claims, there has been a shift to a more populist speech. This changed has not been unnoticed and as it could have been expected, opens the game to further questions.

The last posts of the blog series TERRITORIAL DISPUTES covered Northern Ireland and introduced the notion of self-determination. There are indeed two intertwined concepts: a) the concept of self-determination; and b) the concept of referendum.
For the concept of self-determination, we have reviewed Public International Law (PIL) says about it (see previous posts). To discuss the meaning and reasons behind political speeches and documents may be entertaining but does not offer any real or legal useful tool to understand the Northern Ireland issue.


The same legal concept of self-determination can have different interpretations depending on the interest we support. Because of the vagueness and ambiguity of language, legal norms will necessarily have an open texture. And because of the open texture of language, there will be a core of settledness and a penumbra of unsettledness in every legal rule. In simpler terms, any word (and it also happens in law) can have different meanings; for example, a norm banning “vehicles” from city centres would easily be understood for cars; what about bicycles?

Self-determination as a legal concept has these interpretative problems. The term itself and its components are not clearly defined (what do “people”, “nation”, and “right” mean?). Politicians know that when they use freely the concept of self-determination with a narrow or broad meaning.

Let us bring some light into what appears to be a dark problem. In a simple and schematic way, we may see that:
  • Self-determination is globally recognized as imperative even included in many International Public Law documents.
  • Broadly speaking, it means that people “can decide their destiny.”
  • The term people means inhabitants.
  • Any group of people−inhabitants−can assert their right to self-determination.
  • In consequence, the rest of the international society can only acknowledge their wishes.


A referendum is one of the means to express these wishes. That is to say, a referendum is a general vote by the electorate on a single political question. If applied to self-determination, it usually means that the inhabitants will decide whether to be an independent political organization or remain with the political status they currently have−e.g. a province, an overseas territory, etc.
Although very useful, depending on the way in which a referendum may happen, the question may “suggest” the answer. Hence, it defeats its point (as we have seen in many recent cases: Falklands/Malvinas, Scotland and Brexit). The post tomorrow will refer to referendums in more detail.


NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

Referendum in Northern Ireland
                   
Thursday 04th June 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World

Wednesday, 3 June 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 28) [Post 113]


Northern Ireland and self-determination (cont.)


In cases such as Northern Ireland, to grant self-determination in the form of independence would imply an unbalanced situation amongst the involved agents that may create an unnecessary gap between people who have an otherwise peaceful relationship.

The previous posts this week introduced the notion of self-determination and some of the consequences full independence may bring about. The crucial issue is how self-determination is “weighted”—even considered as a right—against public good, general welfare, a fair and just environment for all (not only the majority or any minority). 
Then, it is not that self-determination is good or bad as a right or as an international remedy per se. Yet, because of the specific situation in which it is applied and the way in which it is used may be.


In cases such as Northern Ireland, a solution between status quo and complete independence should be reached. Some scholars have tried to re-define the idea of self-determination making it more inclusive but somehow giving shape to an eclectic international institution, and that agrees with shared sovereignty:


“[…] the right to national self-determination must go beyond self- government but to stop short of statehood, and thus I introduce a modified right to self-determination, which states that all national groups have an equal right to self-determination provided that the realization of the right does not require the acquisition of independent statehood as a necessary condition.”
Anna Moltchanova, National Self-determination and Justice in Multinational States (Springer, 2011), in partic. p. xvi and Chapter 5.


Hence, if the relationship between a sovereign State and a large group within its population is already problematic, self-determination leading to independence may in fact be a viable solution. However, in the specific case of Northern Ireland in which the involved agents have a peaceful relationship apart from Brexit, to apply self-determination in the form of independence appears as an inadvisable way of dealing with it.

It goes against that relationship and threatens an otherwise peaceful environment. Nevertheless, if self-determination is understood as the collective right a group has to determine their political status, and this group is willing to accept the claims of other agents, it can be an institution that may offer a positive outcome. Besides, it may lead to shared sovereignty, as the next posts will show.


NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

Northern Ireland, self-determination and referendum
                   
Wednesday 03rd June 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World

Tuesday, 2 June 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 27) [Post 112]


Northern Ireland and self-determination (cont.)

Undoubtedly, Brexit will bring changes to the United Kingdom. Unsurprisingly, it will impact Northern Ireland. In fact, Brexit opens many doors for Northern Ireland (doors that previously seemed to be closed).
Yesterday’s post referred to self-determination. It should be clear now independence is not the only way in which self-determination may evolve. Indeed, the population may vote to be administered by, or integrated into, one of the States claiming sovereignty (e.g. Puerto Rico, where the battle is between statehood and independence).

Then self-determination may lead to different results since the population might decide:
  • to be independent;
  • to be administered by or be part of one party—i.e. integration or free association;
  • to have shared sovereignty.


If self-determination leads either to independence or to integration/association, there are reasons why to avoid it is—at least—advisable.
In cases such as Northern Ireland, to grant self-determination in the form of independence would imply an unbalanced situation amongst the involved agents. The fact that Northern Ireland had complete sovereignty would mean that its inhabitants had exclusive prerogatives over the territory including consequent rights and burdens; the rest of the international agents involved would not have any actual or future right or obligation to intervene in its internal or international affairs.
In light of Brexit, an independent Northern Ireland would have to apply to join (or re-join) the European Union. Therefore, if Northern Ireland achieved complete sovereignty they would be outside both the European Union and the United Kingdom. Indeed, it seems like an unreasonable (or not the most advantageous) option.

To leave aside self-determination in the form of independence does not have to do with the international institution itself but with the way it may be applied in this situation.
It might have been useful in historical specific cases due to their own characteristics (e.g. Kosovo). But to use the same international institutions in the same manner in cases in which the interrelation amongst the involved agents is already peaceful—apart from Brexit—adds an unnecessary element of discord that goes against peaceful international relations.

REMINDER: self-determination may imply secession from an already sovereign State. In fact, self-determination can be one of the ways to secede but not the only one. However, to obtain independence through self-determination is not a solution that can be taken automatically in sovereignty issues. It is an ultimum remedium in situations in which a given sovereign State has a certain tension with a group of people, this group of people is large enough, their human rights are not acknowledged, and they have a common identity and decide to be independent; otherwise, their existence within the sovereign State could be compromised. But secession in the form of self-determination is an extreme remedy that may do more harm than good, in some cases.

NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

Northern Ireland and self-determination (cont.)
                   
Tuesday 02nd June 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World

Monday, 1 June 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 26) [Post 111]


Northern Ireland and self-determination


Before going into the way in which we may address the case of Northern Ireland by means of the Egalitarian Shared Sovereignty, it is important to clarify the concept of self-determination.

In the context of international public law, there are several documents that refer to self-determination:

  • Chapter 1, Article 1, part 2 of the UN Charter states amongst its purposes: “To develop friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples, and to take other appropriate measures to strengthen universal peace.”


  • UN General Assembly Resolution 1514 Article 2: “All peoples have the right to self-determination; by virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development.”


  • UN General Assembly Resolution 2649 Article 1: “Affirms the legitimacy of the struggle of peoples under colonial and alien domination recognised as being entitled to the right of self-determination to restore to themselves that right by any means at their disposal.”

  • UN General Assembly Resolution 2625 Article e: “The principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples.”


Although it is often thought to be intrinsically linked to independence, self-determination deserves a separate section because:
  1. there is a vast quantity and variety of documents related to this international institution;
  2. there are many populations around the world at least considering it as an option for their political status;
  3. it may lead to solutions other than independence.


In international relations, self-determination can be understood as a principle that allows a certain group of people who live in a given territory to have the right to decide who will govern them.
Although both are legal and political concepts, sovereignty gives priority to the State whereas self-determination gives preeminent place to the people.
It is not uncommon in sovereignty conflicts that the population of the third territory seeks independence by applying the principle of self-determination. However, the fact that the third territory is granted self-determination—and hence, may become independent—implies always a negative response from at least one of the agents involved in the original conflict.


More precisely, independence is not the only way in which self-determination may evolve. This is key in Northern Ireland since self-determination could enable them to get the best bargaining situation out of Brexit resulting in multiple benefits to current inhabitants and their future generations. In other words, it may be the case that Brexit could be negative in many ways to the United Kingdom. That does not mean it has to be negative for Northern Ireland. In fact, Brexit opens many doors for Northern Ireland (doors that previously seemed to be closed).


NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

Northern Ireland and self-determination (cont.)
                   
Monday 01st June 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World

Friday, 29 May 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 25) [Post 110]

Northern Ireland and the egalitarian shared sovereignty


Different from other territorial disputes in this blog series, with Northern Ireland we followed a different path. 
The first 20 posts (posts 86-105) had to do with European Union law (free movement of persons, European citizenship, free movement of goods, capital and services). 
The last four posts (posts 106-109) introduced very briefly the background situation in Northern Ireland.

Northern Ireland and territory: the egalitarian shared sovereignty

Territory, in principle, can be defined as an area owned and possessed by the population (in land, water, space and, perhaps, cyberspace).
Like population, it may have features that could cause controversy in TERRITORIAL DISPUTES.
Some of the features that constitute territory will be reviewed using the case of Northern Ireland in light of Brexit. Those that introduce controversy will be analyzed using the model proposed here. Next time we center the attention on borders, natural resources and defense.

Let us remember the way in why this series propose to deal with TERRITORIAL DISPUTES via the egalitarian shared sovereignty.
The allocation of sovereignty will be given by:
  • equal right to participate (egalitarian consensus principle);
  • the nature and degree of participation depends on efficiency of accomplishing the particular objective/area/activity at issue (principle of efficiency);
  • each party receives a benefit (in terms of rights and opportunities) that depends on what that party cooperates with (input-to-output ratio principle); and
  • provided the party with greater ability and therefore greater initial participation rights has the obligation to bring the other two parties towards equilibrium (equilibrium proviso).

I call this way of dealing with sovereignty conflicts or disputes the EGALITARIAN SHARED SOVEREIGNTY.


Many questions are to be expected. Amongst them:
  • How is that translated into geographical borders between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland after Brexit?
  • What about the exploration and exploitation of natural resources? This question has two parts:

  1. the sea-zone adjacent to Northern Ireland only; and
  2. the portion that overlaps with the Republic of Ireland.

  • Finally, in the hypothetical scenario that Northern Ireland had a referendum and decided to leave the United Kingdom, who would defend them?


The next posts on this blog series about TERRITORIAL DISPUTES will cover these questions. In order to answer them, the posts will explore the concept of self-determination in the event Northern Ireland decided to have a referendum in the future.


NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

Northern Ireland and self-determination
                   
Friday 29th May 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World

Thursday, 28 May 2020

Territorial disputes: Northern Ireland (Part 24) [Post 109]


Northern Ireland and Brexit on the news


Territorial disputes and sovereignty issues like the one with Northern Ireland, the United Kingdom and the European Union are not rare. True, in light of Brexit, this situation is more than even on the news. However, there are many cases around the world in which several international agents argue about sovereign rights for different reasons over the same piece of land. Despite their many differences, they all have a particular feature: their solution seems to require a mutually exclusive relation amongst the agents because the sovereignty can be for only one of them.

Indeed, sovereignty seems to be an absolute concept (that is to say, exclusive, and not shareable). Therefore, the United Kingdom (hence, Northern Ireland) are in or out the European Union.
Post 7: Territorial disputes: sovereignty
Post 8: Territorial disputes: sovereignty (cont.)

As it stands, the situation in Northern Ireland is a clear example of a zero-sum game, with many negative outcomes of different sorts. The effect of Brexit remains unknown. Yet, it is evident there are many issues at stake domestically and internationally.
Post 9: Territorial disputes: issues at stake

Only to have a glimpse, today’s post includes below a sample of articles from the media covering the case of Northern Ireland. It is evident the information is contradictory and any outcome divides the population’s views about the hard/soft border. Moreover, the last article includes a reference to a point often overlooked and has to do with natural resources.

Although Northern Ireland is not a territorial issue, it has been and is object of study of many sciences—law, political sciences, international relations, only to name a few—these sciences do not share their developments and both different approaches and different languages were applied. Indeed, although multi and inter-disciplinary studies are promoted in speeches everywhere, it is more a nominal aim rather than an actual reality.

I realized that the answer was very simple. Some problems are never solved because most look for more problems, problems within a problem, or just simply give up or are so self-centered they think that problem will not affect them and hence, why would they even think about it. Ergo, the answer came to me: some problems like Northern Ireland evade a solution because people (or their representatives) do not look for answers.

BBC

Theresa May says EU must 'evolve' its Brexit position

“The UK and EU have agreed that there should be no hard border in Ireland, but are at odds over how to achieve it.”
“The EU has proposed a backstop that would mean Northern Ireland staying in the EU customs union, large parts of the single market and the EU VAT system.”
“However, the UK said that would effectively create a border down the Irish Sea.”
“On Friday, Mrs May again repeated her opposition to that, saying: "The economic and constitutional dislocation of a formal 'third country' customs border within our own country is something I will never accept and believe no British prime minister could ever accept".

Belfast Telegraph

Ireland 'will have hardest border in Europe if there's a no deal Brexit'

“In a blunt warning detailing the catastrophe that lies ahead if a 'no deal' Brexit materialises, Joachim Pfeiffer painted a dire picture of the outcome.”

“Mr Pfeiffer said Ireland would "have a border like we have a border with Ukraine or Belarus" as there would no longer be treaties in place with the UK that would ensure the rules and standards of the EU would be respected.”



Sky News

Northern Ireland 'unsupportive' of 'no deal' Brexit, study shows

 “Unionists and nationalists continue to disagree over the location of any physical border after Brexit - unionists opposing an East-West one in the Irish Sea, nationalists opposing a North-South land boundary.”

“But the university researchers who have collated this data believe it has revealed a "point of convergence" on the Irish border issue in operational terms.”

“Their key finding is that unionists and nationalists would both prefer the least intrusive border possible and that there is an arrangement that could command support across the two communities.”



Financial Times

Hard Brexit: the eye-catching contingency plans to stop NI power blackouts

“The situation could come about because Northern Ireland has shared a single energy market with the Irish republic for over a decade, in one of the consequences of the Good Friday Agreement of 1998. Northern Ireland relies on imports from south of the border because it does not have enough generating capacity itself.”

“Britain is hoping to negotiate a deal to allow that single electricity market on the island of Ireland to continue after Brexit.”

“But in the event of a totally disruptive rupture with the bloc Whitehall officials fear that power providers in the republic could end the provision of electricity because the UK would no longer be part of the European electricity market.”



NOTE:  

This post is based on Jorge Emilio Núñez, Territorial Disputes and State Sovereignty. International Law and Politics (Routledge 2020).
Previous published research monograph about territorial disputes and sovereignty by the author, Jorge Emilio Núñez, Sovereignty Conflicts and International Law and Politics: A Distributive Justice Issue London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, 2017.

NEXT POST:

Northern Ireland and the egalitarian shared sovereignty
                   
Thursday 28th May 2020
Dr Jorge Emilio Núñez
Twitter: @DrJorge_World